In letters to officials, MGB primary care doctors say system is closing practices, bleeding physicians

On a gray morning this fall, a packet of letters from frontline clinicians reached state officials with a warning that did not sound like a budget footnote. The doctors said their employer, Mass General Brigham, was shrinking the very practices patients still treat as a front door to medicine. A union speaking for primary care physicians put hard figures beside that warning: 90 doctors gone and five practices closed since 2022, sites that had together served about 35,000 patients. The system disputes the tally. What patients feel either way is the wait, the transfer letter, and the sense that a relationship they counted on has been quietly retired.

What the letters actually ask officials to see

Wooden letters spelling 'What' on a brown cardboard background, close-up view.
Photo by Ann Hannes via Pexels

The correspondence is not a manifesto. It reads more like a clinical note written for people who control licenses, budgets, and public attention. Physicians describe panels that grew after colleagues left, inboxes that never empty, and exam slots booked so far out that a cough becomes an emergency department visit. They ask officials to look past press statements and into the geography of closed doors: which neighborhoods lost a site, which patients were told to travel farther, which doctors were asked to absorb lists they could not honestly manage.

Union leaders frame the letters as a record, not a rumor. They want regulators and elected offices to treat primary care capacity as a public fact, the way hospitals already report emergency crowding. In their telling, a closed practice is not an internal realignment. It is a loss of access that shows up later as delayed cancer screens, unmanaged blood pressure, and families who stop calling because the phone tree no longer connects them to anyone who knows their history.

The count the union is willing to defend

A man holding a 'Count Every Vote' placard, promoting democracy and voting rights.
Photo by Edmond Dantès via Pexels

The headline numbers are specific enough to invite a fight. Ninety physicians departed over roughly four years. Five practices shut. About 35,000 patients had been attached to those sites. The union says the departures are not the ordinary churn of retirement and relocation. It describes a bleed: doctors who wanted to stay in longitudinal care and concluded they could not do the work under current staffing, visit length, and administrative load.

Supporters of the letter campaign argue that headcount alone understates the damage. A departing physician with a full panel is not replaced by a job posting. Replacement takes recruitment, credentialing, and months of trust building. Until then, remaining clinicians inherit messages, refills, and results for people they have never met. The union wants officials to ask whether the system is replacing those 90 roles in primary care, or shifting the work into specialty clinics, urgent care, and hospitals where a simple problem costs more and teaches the patient less.

How the system answers the accusation

A calm man in white stands with closed eyes while several hands point at him in concept of accusation.
Photo by Yan Krukau via Pexels

Mass General Brigham rejects the union portrait of a system closing its way out of primary care. Executives and spokespeople, in public comments on the dispute, have treated the figures as misleading, incomplete, or both. Health systems in this position usually argue that site changes reflect leases, consolidation into larger offices, and a shift toward team based care rather than abandonment. They point to hiring, to new clinicians in training, and to digital tools meant to stretch a limited physician supply.

That answer matters, and it is not automatically false. Large systems do move practices for reasons that are not sinister: a building that cannot support modern infection control, a panel too small to staff safely, a merger that left two offices a few blocks apart. The trouble is that patients experience consolidation as disappearance. A practice that relocates across a river, or folds into a campus with paid parking and a long corridor, can be open on a spreadsheet and closed in the life of an older adult who used to walk there.

Patients caught between two official stories

Two doctors examining a brain X-ray in a clinical setting.
Photo by Vitaly Gariev via Pexels

For the 35,000 people named in the union claim, the argument about methodology is abstract. They need a clinician who will refill a heart medicine without a three month wait, who will notice that a parent has started missing appointments, who will argue with an insurer when a scan is denied. When a practice closes, those tasks do not vanish. They migrate to whoever answers the phone, often a covering doctor with no memory of the case and no time to build one.

Massachusetts has long sold itself as a state where coverage is broad and academic medicine is close at hand. Coverage is not the same as a relationship. A card in a wallet does not produce an opening on a Tuesday. Families describe calling a central scheduling line and learning that the next new patient visit sits seasons away, or that the doctor they were assigned has already left. The letters ask officials to treat that experience as data, not as anecdote from people who failed to navigate the portal.

Why primary care keeps losing the internal argument

Scrabble tile letters spelling 'Improve Your Argument' on a pink background.
Photo by DS stories via Pexels

Inside large health systems, primary care is praised in strategy documents and squeezed in the weekly schedule. A visit that is supposed to hold prevention, a new symptom, and a life update is booked for a slice of time that assumes none of those things will be complicated. Documentation, prior authorization, and quality metrics then consume the evening. Physicians who came to the work for continuity find themselves managing a queue. Some leave for concierge models, specialty training, or jobs that pay them to advise rather than to sit with patients. Others leave medicine altogether.

The economics are stubborn. Procedures and hospital days still generate more revenue than a careful conversation about sleep, grief, or a medication that is not working. When margins tighten, the sites that look inefficient on a dashboard are the small offices with high no show rates and patients who need interpreters, social work, and longer visits. Closing them can improve a financial report while worsening the health of the people who used them. The union letters are, in part, a demand that this tradeoff be named in public.

Burnout that looks like a resignation letter

Overhead shot of a partially eaten cake with 'Happy Burnout' message on a marble surface.
Photo by Nataliya Vaitkevich via Pexels

National surveys of clinicians have described exhaustion, moral distress, and intent to leave for years. The Boston fight gives those abstractions a local face. Doctors writing to officials are not only bargaining over wages, though pay and staffing are never far from the page. They are describing a kind of moral injury: being asked to carry responsibility for outcomes they no longer have the time to influence. A physician who cannot see a diabetic patient before the year ends is still the name on the quality report when the lab values worsen.

Departure then gets misread as personal failure or lifestyle preference. Some of it is ordinary life: a spouse relocates, a physician retires after a long career, a new graduate chooses a different city. The union claim is that the volume since 2022 exceeds that baseline, and that closed practices are the institutional signature of the same pressure. If officials want a fair count, they can request turnover by site, vacancy duration, and panel size before and after each closure. Those are auditable facts. They do not require anyone to take a press release on faith.

Neighborhoods and the quiet map of access

Stack of yellow QR code markers placed on a detailed map for location tracking and navigation.
Photo by Tahir Xəlfəquliyev via Pexels

Five closed practices do not land evenly. Primary care is local in a way that quaternary hospitals are not. People choose a doctor because the office is near a bus line, because the staff speaks their language, because a neighbor said the clinician listens. When that office goes dark, the replacement offered by a central system may be clinically excellent and still unusable. Evening hours disappear. A grandparent who combined a visit with a grocery trip cannot do both. Adolescents who trusted one clinician stop coming rather than retell their story to a stranger.

Urban hospital systems sometimes answer this by opening larger hubs and promising transportation help or virtual visits. Virtual care is a real tool for refills and simple follow up. It is a poor substitute for the first meeting with a frightened patient, for a physical exam, for the unscheduled comment that reveals elder abuse or a plan to stop a medication. The letters, as described by the doctors union, ask the state to notice which communities absorbed the closures and whether replacement capacity is actually reachable.

Training more doctors will not fix a leak this fast

Group of medical students practicing skills with a training mannequin in a classroom setting.
Photo by Duy Tân Đại học via Pexels

Massachusetts trains a remarkable share of the nations physicians. That fact is often offered as reassurance when access stories break. Training is slow, and new graduates do not automatically choose primary care in the systems that frustrated their teachers. Residents watch attending physicians stay late to finish notes. They hear that panels are closed. They compare salaries with procedural fields and make rational choices. A pipeline that produces specialists for export does not, by itself, restaff a neighborhood office in Dorchester or a suburban site that lost its last full time clinician.

Loan repayment, team staffing with nurses and pharmacists, and schedules that protect continuity can change those choices. None of that arrives because a letter was sent. It arrives when boards and public agencies treat primary care workforce as a constraint on every other goal the system advertises, from equity to cost control. The union is betting that outside readers, including officials who do not sit in the budget meeting, will apply that pressure.

A local dispute inside a national shortage

Empty supermarket shelves in Bielefeld, Germany, depicting a shortage or high demand situation.
Photo by Patrick Winzler via Pexels

Boston is not unique. Across the country, patients report months long waits for a new primary clinician, and health systems report that they cannot hire fast enough. Retail clinics and virtual companies have rushed into the gap, sometimes usefully, sometimes by skimming straightforward visits and leaving complex patients to whoever remains. Academic systems feel the strain in a particular way because they also run research, teaching, and high end specialty care that dominate headlines and philanthropy.

The argument over 90 physicians is therefore both a labor dispute and a test of whether a flagship system will be judged by its transplant reputation or by its ordinary Tuesdays. If the union numbers are inflated, the system should publish a clearer ledger: openings, closures, net primary care physicians, and patients reassigned within a defined travel time. If the numbers are roughly right, the public deserves a plan that is more concrete than a promise to innovate. Either outcome is better than a stalemate in which each side accuses the other of bad faith while appointment slots vanish.

What officials can do without picking a winner

A referee declares the winner of an indoor boxing match, raising their arm in victory.
Photo by César O'neill via Pexels

State agencies do not run Mass General Brigham, and they should not pretend to. They do license facilities, oversee insurance markets, and spend public money on care for people who have no private alternative. They can require timely reporting when a primary care site closes or when a panel is frozen to new patients. They can ask how many of the departed physicians were replaced by clinicians actually seeing patients in the same communities. They can examine whether network adequacy rules mean anything if a covered patient cannot get a visit.

They can also resist the temptation to treat the letters as campaign literature and stop there. Unions advocate. Systems defend their balance sheets. Patients live in the space between those incentives. A serious response looks like questions with deadlines: where did the five practices go, who absorbed the 35,000, how long are new patient waits by region, and what staffing standard will keep the next office from closing. Those questions do not require officials to endorse every sentence in the correspondence. They require officials to notice that primary care is being described, by the people who do it, as a service in retreat.

The relationship medicine keeps saying it values

Hands holding a red heart-shaped tin with the message 'A heart a day keeps the doctor away' on a marble surface.
Photo by kaboompics via Pexels

There is a quieter claim inside the labor fight, and it is the one that outlasts any quarterly report. Primary care is a practice of attention. It works when a clinician can remember who this person is, what they feared last winter, which medicine they will not take, which family member should be in the room. That kind of knowledge is not a software feature. It is built by showing up in the same office, year after year, with enough time to listen. When physicians leave in large numbers and practices shut, the institution loses more than full time equivalents. It loses memory.

Readers far from Boston can recognize the pattern in their own towns: the clinic that became a chain pharmacy, the doctor who stopped taking new patients, the portal message that goes unanswered for a week. The letters now sitting with officials are a local attempt to make that pattern undeniable. Whether the precise count is 90 or something lower, the underlying question will not close with a clarification statement. Can a system as large and celebrated as this one keep a promise that is small on paper and enormous in a life: that someone who knows you will still be there when you call?